You might see that the Dropbox Community team have been busy working on some major updates to the Community itself! So, here is some info on what’s changed, what’s staying the same and what you can expect from the Dropbox Community overall.
Forum Discussion
Can I backup Dropbox folder to external disk with Time Machine?
I've read lots of posts about various Time Machine topics but I'm unable to find a definite answer to my questions:
1) Can I backup Dropbox folder (including subfolders and files) to external disk with Time Machine?
2) If it's possible - how should I go about this exactly (not using smart sync etc)?
As Dropbox is a sync service and not a backup service it's important for me to know how to go about the backing up of all folders and files I currently have in Dropbox. At the moment I have the entire Dropbox folder excluded from Time Machine backups since I'm unsure about how/if it would work to include it.
Hi Anna R.5, thanks for posting today!
I wouldn’t recommend backing up the Dropbox folder to Time Machine for various reasons.
First of all, Time Machine creates multiple backups, and restoring your Dropbox folder from one of these backups might not have the same permissions as the original folder, and could create conflicted copies, thus duplicating your data.
Secondly, if you are using Smart Sync, you won’t gain any benefit, since it only saves the placeholder files and not the actual files themselves. Restoring from a backup might overwrite the real files from the site.
Lastly, this would cause a massive resyncing of files when restored, and even when making backups to Time Machine, it could be detected as a change to a file, affecting the version history of the real file.
If you are planning to make a backup of your Dropbox folder, I’d recommend doing it manually to another drive, and not through an automatic system which constantly monitors the Dropbox folder.
I hope this helps to clarify matters!
- Jay
Dropbox Staff
Hi Anna R.5, thanks for posting today!
I wouldn’t recommend backing up the Dropbox folder to Time Machine for various reasons.
First of all, Time Machine creates multiple backups, and restoring your Dropbox folder from one of these backups might not have the same permissions as the original folder, and could create conflicted copies, thus duplicating your data.
Secondly, if you are using Smart Sync, you won’t gain any benefit, since it only saves the placeholder files and not the actual files themselves. Restoring from a backup might overwrite the real files from the site.
Lastly, this would cause a massive resyncing of files when restored, and even when making backups to Time Machine, it could be detected as a change to a file, affecting the version history of the real file.
If you are planning to make a backup of your Dropbox folder, I’d recommend doing it manually to another drive, and not through an automatic system which constantly monitors the Dropbox folder.
I hope this helps to clarify matters!
Hi Jay,
I was curious about your response. What do you mean that we should backup Dropbox files to "another drive"?
How can I do this?
I, too, want to find a way to backup my Dropbox files.Thank you.
- Daphne
Hey LJC, thanks for joining the discussion!
Usually, using another drive as a place to hold your data backups is the most common location. Most probably in case the primary drive that you're using needs to be reformatted or fails unexpectedly.
However, you can make a backup of the Dropbox folder by simply copying the Dropbox folder and placing this copy anywhere that you'd like to keep your backup.
Since the Dropbox folder is just like any other folder on your computer, you can use the same steps as you usually would to create a copy of a folder on your computer. You can do a quick web search for how to do this based on your device's OS if you're not sure.
I hope this helps!
Thank you Jay .
Now I know I should not include my Dropbox folder in Time Machine backup. If it had been a possible solution I would have turned off Smart Sync of course, but I gather from your answer that it would not be a recommended solution even with Smart Sync turned off.
I understand that you recommend manual backup for files in Dropbox folder. However, this is not a viable solution (for most I think). Do you know how other people solve this? What is the recommended solution from Dropbox, please (except for manual backup)?
- Jay
Each user has their own preference, some have scripts setup to simply copy the Dropbox folder to an external drive, others upload via FTP to off-site storage, it can vary.
While I can’t provide any recommendations on how to do this, I’m sure some other users on the Community will have something to share from their end!
