End of support for OS X 10.4 and 10.5

[Matthew S.]

Why pull support and remove functionality? Why not just drop support -- just stop updating the app but still allow basic functionality? There are still a lot of legacy machines that are still in use and CANNOT upgrade to 10.6, as they are PowerPC based. Yes, old systems still work. Why stop the app from working totally instead of just deprecating support for those systems?

[Peter L.3]

Yes. Please keep it working. I have an old intel based macbookpro that runs software I need so I can't quit it. I need dropbox too on that computer.

[Dieter V.]

+1 against pulling the support. I use these older PPC - Mac os 10.4 machines every day.

[Franz S.]

Same here, please don't turn it off. Without Dropbox, I couldn't use my PowerBook anymore. And I love my PowerBook.

[Siggi V.]

What a sad email this is from DropBox to not support our wonderfully stable G5 towers anymore. I still use my G5 Quad a lot though I have an i7 intel quad as well. I do hope they will reconsider seeing what a huge number of G5's are still in use all over the world. This looks like a strange misunderstanding when they say; "But you'll need to update your computer to OS X Snow Leopard 10.6 or later". How can they not know their suggestion is impossible?

[Martin K.8]

Dear members of Dropbox team,

today I received your e-mail about ending support for Mac OS X 10.4 and 10.5. and I want to say something about that.

I am member of small but not-dead-yet worldwide community of users of Mac computers equipped with PowerPC microprocessors. Since 2005, when Apple announced switch to Intel CPUs, support for our computers vanished from almost all kinds of applications. Dropbox was one of the last still supporting us and I want to thank you for that effort. Let me just ask you not to cut us off.

You advise us to upgrade to OS X 10.6, which will still be supported after May 18th. This makes little sense to me, since there are just seven Mac models from 2006, for which 10.6 is the final version, all newer can upgrade to 10.7. On the other hand, Mac OS X 10.4 or 10.5 is the final version for much more computers, all Apple computers from summer 2000 to the end of 2005 to be exact. There are even some 1999 Mac models that can run 10.4 and many older can be upgraded to do so - with proper CPU upgrade it's possible to use Dropbox from Mac made in 1995. So with this one step you will cut off the whole decade of computers, but you will still support seven models from 2006, some of which have less CPU power than final PowerPC models from 2005.

I started with Dropbox five years ago on my on PowerMac G5 and now I still use it on that very same PowerMac G5 with OS X 10.5 as well as on PowerBook G4 with OS X 10.4, Lenovo T400 with Linux, HP desktop with Windows 7, iPad and BlackBerry Z10. You can probably say, that removing two computers from this list will do a little harm, but the opposite is true: I have Dropbox installed on all my computers to get my data to the PowerMac G5 on which I do all my typing, programming, photo editing, etc. Two months ago I even bought Samsung camera with Dropbox support to get pictures to this desktop without wires, now my complete ecosystem will be broken with demise of its central element.

Without my PowerMac, it has no sense for me to use Dropbox on other machines and devices. Even after you stop supporting 10.4/10.5 there will probably be some ways how to sync on these systems, like installing qemu (or other x86 PC emulator) with Linux and sync Dropbox via shared folder from this emulation. But I don't want to do things this ridiculous just to have my favorite cloud service on my favorite computer. So please, reconsider support for 10.4/10.5, you still support Windows XP (2001) and our systems are no older than this one.

Thank you.

Martin Kukač, Dropbox AND PowerMac user

Notice: This is an open letter from http://vivapowerpc.blogspot.cz/2015/01/an-open-letter-to-dropbox-team.html

[Jan H.4]

I was shocked by the email too. I have used dropbox for years, and I was quite satisfied with it. Updating OS is not a possibility for me, so this means the end... :(((

[Colin W.1]

I need 10.5.8 PPC to run 68k os9 emulation for accounts package with 20 years accumulated data. I like having that backed up by Dropbox but I guess there are other options I can look into.
Like everyone else I want to know why there is no option for "let the old app run", and to SEE the reasoning (which may well be reasonable in terms of security or whatever).
Where would be a good place to share ideas for lua/python/other scripts to provide single file get and send from Dropbox scripts?
Dropbox folk: would you support and help such ideas? It is tough not knowing your thinking on why the chop!!

[John R.3]

I'm a PowerBook G4 user and use Dropbox as part of my workflow. Please keep it ticking over on the existing version, there's no need to block older machines.

['- -.1]

I agree with you, Martin!
One of the strongest points of Dropbox was that it was available for almost everything. Now that the Linux client uses QT which is ugly and resource hungry and buggy and no support for PowerPC macs, this is gone.
I run Dropbox on my G4 Mini, Powermac G5, two Intel Macbooks, a couple of Intel Mac Pros, where I use Bootcamp with Windows and Windows version of Dropbox and a couple of Linux laptops. Now that Linux client is of little to no use and no support for PowerPC macs I might as well go with Microsoft's service which is built into Windows and supports newer macs.
Not that I think a lot of PowerPC users are paying customers so this decision may be right business-wise, on the other hand a lot of these people also use Dropbox on other platforms/newer operating systems and recommend Dropbox to others because of that.
Windows XP support is just confusing, but actually Apple did exactly the same thing when dropped the support for 10.4 releasing no iTunes updates while supporting XP. I do know that XP has a larger user base, especially corporate so it's also reasonable from the business point of view.
While I understand the reasoning for dropping support, it's still sad. I think no new features for older macs would be okay for everyone, even no updates at all would. But why forcing them out? The only thing that comes to mind is a major protocol change. PowerPC mac users are a strong community, there are even projects poring modern software exclusively to older macs, like TenFourFox and TigerBrew, these people aren't going anywhere anytime soon. I really hope that Dropbox team reconsiders.

[Jason M.2]

We JUST started using Dropbox here at the University I work at for a huge project involving a large digital video archive that we thought was lost. The software we have to use won't run on newer machines than PPC.
The plan was to edit and process all of this archived video and then use Dropbox to move it to more modern Macs for final production and proper archiving.
Please don't make us hunt around for another solution (that works as simply as Dropbox).